Paul’s “Thorn In The Flesh”
Pauline Propaganda:
“Paul had a nasty, incurable eye disease, and God said, ‘Live with it’!”
In the quest for truth, one of the first things we learn to watch out for is hearsay and unfounded stories. Some stories we call “lies” and others we just call “rumors”. The only difference is that one is intentionally perpetrated in order to dissuade, deflect or confuse and that one is called a “lie”. The other is caused through mere carelessness or the believing another’s ignorant conclusion making. That is the kind that we call rumor. Rumor spread to other people for a desired response becomes propaganda.
Pauline Propaganda:
“Paul had a nasty, incurable eye disease, and God said, ‘Live with it’!”
In the quest for truth, one of the first things we learn to watch out for is hearsay and unfounded stories. Some stories we call “lies” and others we just call “rumors”. The only difference is that one is intentionally perpetrated in order to dissuade, deflect or confuse and that one is called a “lie”. The other is caused through mere carelessness or the believing another’s ignorant conclusion making. That is the kind that we call rumor. Rumor spread to other people for a desired response becomes propaganda.
A rumor looks at things with a quick glance, without digging deeper, without gathering real evidence. A rumor often follows the bent of a person’s heart and what they “want” to think or report about something. It reads into events and statements and creates its own “new” truth. It somehow knows that it is being “careless”, but doesn’t really care, as long as it gets peoples’ attention or influences people in some way.
In fact, often a rumor is quickly created for the sake of the creator – the person starting such statements and stories, because that person is anxious to discredit some one or some thing. The person who starts rumors often has admitted issues of the heart, and therefore does not pursue the truth but rather his or her own selfish motives.
In some cases, a rumor is started to cover up ones own inadequacies. For instance, a rumor can be used by someone who would like to believe that there is nothing wrong with his own faith and prayers, since he tried to pray for healing for someone and it never came. What a better thing if he can latch onto a good-sounding story to justify his own or someone else’s shortcoming.
Worse yet, a rumor can be used to attempt financial advantage, political sway, and protect “sacred cows”. What preacher wants to risk offending those generous tithers who make their money in the medical profession if he can come up with a scripture-quoting rumor to convince the others that God needs the medical professionals?
Amazingly, in the face of hundreds of scriptures which point to the will of God to perform healing and forgiveness for all, today’s preachers continue to pass along a mere “rumor” – a lie as the devil certainly knows it is – the dramatic caveat or “tragic exception” to the “God wishes to heal all sickness” truth found in the Word of God!
Recently I attended a church, having just spent time in the Word myself that morning at home. The Lord had taken me to James five – the whole chapter. I wasn’t looking for the “healing passage” (James 5:13-18); I just happened to end up there.
I remember reading right before these verses pertaining to healing, and thinking how practical James was: “If you are this, then do that”; “If you need that, then do this” et cetera. That morning in this conservative church, didn’t the pastor start out by saying basically the same thing! “Hmmm, so far so good,” I thought.
However, having noticed what his sermon was titled – The Issue of Divine Healing – I was still braced for what might follow. Sadly, something from a “different spirit” did take over the rest of the message. Faith building you ask? Let’s call it faith busting!
He began by reading the passage in James, and noted how easy it sounded, and how conclusive it appeared. He said, “One might get the impression from this that the Lord wants to heal every sickness.” In the echo of the entire Word of God – that would be a “duh”, and he should have ended his sermon after that first sentence!
But he went on to present an unfortunate tragic caveat – a mere rumor and an easily disproven one at that – to negate the all-inclusiveness of the passage in James, as well as the rest of the Gospels and so much of the Bible.
You see, folks, Paul – according to this rumor – himself had a sickness, and God told him He would not heal it for him!
He could have just as easily reported that Paul had a sin and God told Paul He would not forgive it. As we read throughout the entire scriptures, both of these statements would be equal.
The pastor took us to II Corinthians 12:7 – 10. With that scripture he added one of the most anti-faith rumors to hit the Body of Christ, and proceeded to preach “doubt” and unbelief for the remainder of his sermon.
The passage reads as follows:
“And lest I should be exalted above measure through the abundance of the revelations, there was given me a thorn in the flesh, the messenger of Satan to buffet me, lest I should be exalted above measure. For this thing I besought the Lord thrice, that it might depart from me. And He said unto me, My grace is sufficient for thee: for my strength is made perfect in weakness. Most gladly therefore will I rather glory in my infirmities, that the power of Christ may rest upon me. Therefore I take pleasure in infirmities, in reproaches, in necessities, in persecutions, in distresses for Christ’s sake: for when I am weak, then am I strong” (II Cor.12:7-10).
From this passage alone and some extremely careless exegesis, the pastor fell tragically victim to the rumor that keeps millions from receiving their blood-bought “right” to healing from the Cross of Jesus. Call him a rumor bearer or pall bearer – they both add up to the same thing: the Gospel of Jesus denigrated in its purchase, its purpose, its meaning and its ministration.
Just think, the sick – both present and future, suffering, dying, leaving behind them hurt and cheated loved ones and family, leaving unfinished calls given them by God – have been deceived out of their divine, “miraculous” healing from God – and all from a mere rumor!
I went home troubled and stirred in my spirit, thinking, “This man just got away with murder!” I poured back into the Word and some of my books again to see how in the world supposed theologians could find any excuse to report this as being in the Word of God.
Interestingly, I noted that only those who fully believed in the atoning work of Jesus to defeat all the works of the devil (sin and sickness) showed true thoroughness in looking into the true meaning of the phrase “thorn in the flesh”. Only from these individuals did I see any close examination as to what it always referred to in scripture, and what it never referred to in scripture (i.e. disease).
Actually, there are many writers who go to great length pointing this out. F. F. Bosworth writes with great thoroughness in Christ The Healer, as does T. L. Osborn in Healing The Sick. My guess is that only those with the faith that has seen results have the courage to truly seek out the real truth behind this passage.
For if one accurately searches out the meaning of this passage, he or she will find that in no way does this passage negate the fact that God does wish to heal all diseases!
While these great authors do go into great detail, I will only provide the highlights here. My purpose is not to convince you or win you in argument. My purpose is to call your attention to something purported to be truth which is in fact a lie, and I urge you to check it out for yourself.
In highlight and summary, however, I would like to present the following facts.
First, the word for “thorn” is not a thing, but actually a person. The Greek word used for thorn is “angelos” – a being, actually a “messenger”. In fact, Paul’s use of Greek language attributes to this person or being a gender of “male”. The problem is, the idea of “disease” in Greek has no gender!
This word “angelos” is used 188 times in the Bible. It is used as “messenger” seven times, and as “angel” 181 times. It always refers to a person and never to a thing. That is, in its 188 times used in the Word of God, it is NEVER used to refer to disease!
Furthermore, throughout the Old Testament, whenever it is used it is always followed by a reference to the “persons” it is referring to. One example of that is the Canaanites. In Numbers 33:55 we read, “If ye will not drive out the inhabitants of the land (Canaan) from before you; then it shall come to pass that those which ye let remain of them shall be pricks in your eyes and thorns in your sides, and shall vex you in the land wherein ye dwell.”
Secondly, it was always used as an “expression”, and never to any actual literal “thing”. It never describes something literally sticking into or affecting in any physical way someone’s flesh! It always rather describes problematic persons or beings.
Today we use the expression “pain in the butt” when referring to annoying people or events. This never means a literal malfunction or discomfort in ones gluteus maximus! Neither did this Biblical phrase “thorn in the flesh” ever refer to a literal physical disfunction or ailment in ones skin or flesh.
Yet, if the child of a chiropractor were to ask her dad to do something about her ‘pain in the butt’ (little sister), so the dad might say, “No I won’t. You’ll learn how to deal with her (not “it”) like a big girl”.
So, let’s rephrase this little dialogue: “I asked my Daddy to get rid of my ‘pain in the butt’, but he told me he wasn’t going to do that, because I was old enough to learn to handle her myself.”
What an insult and horrible rumor if someone reported the chiropractor telling his own child, “No, I won’t take care of that myofascial pain you are experiencing in your body (your proverbial “butt”). Just deal with it!”
How horrible to report that that chiropractor will help other people but not his very own daughter!
Yet this is the horrible discrediting of the blood of Jesus and the heart of the Father that happened in that church that morning. Sadly, the same report happens over and over across the land. This is the horrible report that men and women “in the name of Jesus” state – that God actually told Paul He would not take his disease away! Nothing could be further from the heart of the Father towards Paul or towards us.
Third, the mission of this “thorn” Paul said was “to buffet”. The word used for buffet is kolaphizō, and the action of it is “blow after blow”, or violent “fist after fist”. This word, as well, is NEVER ANYWHERE used in scripture in discussing disease.
Fourth, Paul, with regularity not matched by any other Biblical writer, often described in words the many things he endured at the hands of Satan. Here’s a few:
· Chastened and not killed
· Stripes above measure
· In prisons more frequent
· In deaths often
· Five times received I forty stripes save one
· Thrice was I beaten with rods
· Once was I stoned
· Imprisonments
· Tumults
· Dishonor
· Evil report
· Disputing continually with false brethren
· In perils of robbers
· In perils of mine own countrymen
· In perils by the heathen
· In perils in the city
· In perils in the wilderness
· In perils in the sea
· In perils among false brethren
· In weariness
· In hunger and thirst
· In cold
· Naked
· Reviled
· Persecuted
· Defamed
· Made as the filth of the world
The man was not timid with words! He also was in no way hesitant to talk about all the things he endured on a continual basis – from the smallest to the greatest, from mere weariness to being beaten with rods.
· In prisons more frequent
· In deaths often
· Five times received I forty stripes save one
· Thrice was I beaten with rods
· Once was I stoned
· Imprisonments
· Tumults
· Dishonor
· Evil report
· Disputing continually with false brethren
· In perils of robbers
· In perils of mine own countrymen
· In perils by the heathen
· In perils in the city
· In perils in the wilderness
· In perils in the sea
· In perils among false brethren
· In weariness
· In hunger and thirst
· In cold
· Naked
· Reviled
· Persecuted
· Defamed
· Made as the filth of the world
The man was not timid with words! He also was in no way hesitant to talk about all the things he endured on a continual basis – from the smallest to the greatest, from mere weariness to being beaten with rods.
Don’t you think it strange that never ONCE did he include in those discussions that he endured sickness – of any sort? Not once!
And if in fact he did have the horrible eye illness (opthalmia) that the rumor describes (which undoubtedly would have been affecting him as he even wrote those words, would it not), don’t you think it strange that he in all of his writings never mentioned such a horrible disease – not even once?
Particularly, if this one disease was that “thorn” that he had sought the Lord so much about and was the one affliction he would have to live with, most certainly he would have cited “disease” at least a few times in his list of trials. Yet not even once did he do so.
If Paul was so open and honest about his many physical trials, and HE never spoke about constant affliction with any disease, how presumptuous it would be for someone to base a whole doctrine – particularly one which would do such horrible damage to peoples’ faith – on a rumor, which is never even alluded to by Paul himself nor in any other way proven or even supported in the least little way!
The fact is, this story is a rumor, and is in fact a lie! Sadly it draws people away from the Cross daily. It deliberately steers people away from that which Jesus suffered and died for, but all for this insidious rumor, died for in vain.
If you were a parent and you declared the following statements regarding your care for your children, see how you would feel if one of your children came and you told them you refused to heal them. The mere possibility of an exception being made for someone as faithful as Paul, asking God so consistently for what is promised for all of His children, is ludicrous.
· (Psalm 103:3) (He) forgives all yours sins and heals all your diseases
· (Ex. 15:26) He said, “If you listen carefully to the voice of the Lord your God and do what is right in his eyes, if you pay attention to his commands and keep all his decrees, I will not bring on you any of the diseases I brought on the Egyptians, for I am the Lord, who heals you.”
· (Matt. 4:24) News about him (Jesus) spread all over Syria, and people brought to him all who were ill with various diseases, those suffering severe pain, the demon-possessed, those having seizures, and the paralyzed, and he healed them.
· (Matt. 8:16) When evening came, many who were demon-possessed were brought to him, and he drove out the spirits with a word and healed all the sick.
· (Matt. 12:15) Aware of this, Jesus withdrew from that place. Many followed him, and He healed all their sick
· (Matt. 14:14) When Jesus landed and saw a large crowd, he had compassion on them and healed their sick.
· (Matt. 14:36) and all who touched him were healed.
· (Mark 6:56) And wherever he went-into villages, towns or countryside-they placed the sick in the marketplaces. They begged him to let them touch even the edge of his cloak, and all who touched him were healed.
· (Acts 5:16) Crowds gathered also from the towns around Jerusalem, bringing their sick and those tormented by evil* spirits, and all of them were healed.
· (I Pet. 2:24) He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree, so that we might die to sins and live for righteousness; by his wounds you have been healed.
How careless, how callous, how truly wicked to draw a precious believer away from wonderful promises in the Word of God on the basis of such an ill-founded, ignorance-driven, heresaical lie!
If you ever think about spreading a rumor that poses such great exception to a “rule” or truth taught in scriptures, you better make extra sure that your exception is founded in truth – over and over, and beyond a shadow of a doubt – lest you became guilty of “taking away from the Word of God”!
The blood of billions of lives cut short by disease and aided and abetted by these careless preachers is on those preachers’ hands!
For all those preachers who have willingly preached this lie (or let’s just call it a “rumor”, in case they honestly did their best to exegete it properly), receive now the following warning from Revelation 22.19:
“And if anyone takes words away from this book of prophecy, God will take away from him his share in the tree of life and in the holy city, which are described in this book.”
(Post note: Exactly one month later - to the day – after preaching this sermon, the pastor referred to in this chapter submitted his resignation due to “moral failure”.)
(Post note: Exactly one month later - to the day – after preaching this sermon, the pastor referred to in this chapter submitted his resignation due to “moral failure”.)